Can you get Covered CA Subsidies if your
Employer offers “Affordable Health Coverage?”
“Family Glitch”

If your employer health plan offers you  affordable coverage and it has

neither you or your family qualifies for the APTC Advance Premium Tax Credit-subsidy from Covered CA, Health Care.Gov or any exchange. Covered CA FAQ   

This employee only contribution percentage is all the  Employer Shared Responsibility Mandate Provision requires to avoid penalties for employers with over 50 employees. 

It doesn’t matter if covering your whole family coverage would go over the 9.83% limit.  That just the way the law and rulings work.  Some call this the “Family Glitch.”

There is some talk about fixing this SNAFU, but it  would likely involve changing the eligibility calculation for marketplace subsidies — pegging the affordability standard to the coverage cost of the whole family rather than just an individual’s coverage. Doing so would increase federal spending by about $9 billion or $10 billion, since many more people would qualify for subsidies. CA Health Line *

Note that if rates increase or employer contribution lowers, that may trigger a special enrollment period, rather than wait for open enrollment.

See also the 8% rule if you want an exemption from the individual mandate or permission to get a catastrophic – minimum coverage plan.

Cal Choice Premium Affordability Calculator

Note also, that ARPA the 2021 American Rescue Plan limits your family contribution to 8.5% for all income limits Income ChartPremium, Benefit & Subsidy calculator.

SNAFU - Situation Normal - All Fouled Up

I learned the word SNAFU  Situation Normal, All Fouled Up  in the dorm, when I attended San Diego State in the early 70's and earned a degree in Insurance.  In all that time, I've never been able to use the word in a sentence, until last 10.1.2013, when Covered, Health Care.Gov nor the Insurance Company Websites or my own Quote Engine that I pay around $250/month for were supposed to launch, but did not do it properly.

Questions About 8% Rule and possible Exemption from Mandated Health Insurance

Question if Employer Coverage offered?

Covered CA Questions on Employer Provided Coverage – Concerning 9.5% rule


Another Question for ANY Health Care Program

Citations & Details

Example 2. Basic determination of affordability for a related individual. The facts are the same as in Example 1, except that C is married to J and X’s plan requires C to contribute $5,300 for coverage for C and J for 2014 (11.3 percent of C’s household income). Because C’s required contribution for self-only coverage ($3,450) does not exceed 9.5 percent of household income, under paragraph (c)(3)(v)(A)( 2 ) of this section, X’s plan is affordable for C and J, and C and J are eligible for minimum essential coverage for all months in 2014 CFR §1.36 B 2 Eligibility for Premium Tax Credit

However, the cost of a family plan is often higher, but the ruling means that those higher costs will not be considered even if the extra premiums push the cost of coverage above the 9.5% income threshold. The New York Times said this could leave 2–4 million Americans unable to afford family coverage under their employers’ plans and ineligible for subsidies to buy coverage elsewhere.[136][137]  Wikipedia

Alternatives – Solutions?

One possible solution to the Family Issue would be to have the Employer get a program thru the SHOP exchange, Kaiser Direct or check with us [email protected] many other companies may do it, exclude dependents, then they are NOT eligible and can then select “None of the Above” and get subsidies based on household income.

Insure Me Explanation 9.29.2015

Self Employed Health Care Deduction?

More Explanation

Under the law, those workers whose employers offer “affordable coverage” will not be eligible for subsidies in the exchanges. To be eligible, per the law’s definition, the cost of employer-based health insurance must exceed 9.5% of the worker’s household income. In January 2013 the Internal Revenue Service (CFR 1.36 B 2) ruled that only the cost of covering the individual employee would be considered in determining whether the cost of coverage exceeded 9.5% of income.

Metal Levels – Bronze 60% Actuarial Value –

Minimum Value Definition ==>An employer-sponsored plan provides minimum value if it covers at least 60 percent of the total allowed cost of benefits that are expected to be incurred under the plan. See Notice 2014-69 for additional guidance regarding whether an employer-sponsored plan provides minimum value coverage if the plan fails to substantially cover in-patient hospitalization services or physician services  *  Covered CA Bulletin page 2  * Our Ben E Lect Webpage  * Employer is mandated to tell you 1095 C  *  IRS  Notice 2012-31 *

Covered CA Certified Agent

#Covered CA Certified Agent  

No extra charge for complementary assistance 

Videos on how great agents are

I'm in Sonia VIDEO

I'm in Sonia


11 comments on “Affordable Employer Health Coverage? Employee ONLY 9.86% Family Glitch

  1. My wife and I are covered under my companies insurance, but are wondering if covered cal. would be less.

    Our combined income is around $90,000.00 a year.

    Please provide what the cost for insurance would be if we switched.

    • Besides income and family size, Income Chart, rates go by zip code and your age.

      Here’s our instant quote engine

      See above about the family glitch and the questions Covered CA asks if you have employer coverage available.

      Let us know what employer coverage you have and what your contribution is and we can see if you’re eligible or not. Our email is encrypted and we have confidential upload.

  2. How is this rule enforced? I don’t see any place on my tax return 1040 or #8962 Premium Tax Credit asking about if coverage was offered to my whole family, at a ridicules’ price?

    • Here’s the reply we got from Covered CA on 1.27.2020

      Covered CA does not enforce any of the penalties, so if there is a household that received premium assistance and should not have been eligible for it, they would need to work that out with the IRS. It would be the same if they did not receive premium assistance they should have been eligible for.

      Maybe the IRS would know if they match up the 1095’s A Individual **** B Employer?

      Here’s a bulletin we just got today on a proposed CMS rule:

      end automatic enrollment for low-income exchange enrollees who receive $0 premium plans with tax credits.

      automatic re-enrollment may lead to incorrect expenditures of (advanced premium tax credit), some of which cannot be recovered through the reconciliation process due to statutory caps.

      health insurers to implement copay accumulator programs to prevent drug manufacturer coupons from going toward a patient’s annual limit on out-of-pocket costs when a generic drug is available.

  3. Am I eligible for a subsidy if I elect and am on COBRA coverage?

    Even if I have a poverty-level income for the year?

  4. My wife, son (age 11) and I have marketplace – Covered CA Oscar insurance this year. The premium is $175/month after ACA subsidy based on projected 2018 income of $75k for 3-person household.

    My employer just offered us medical insurance, which means family glitch. However, there is no employer contribution to the premium for my dependents.

    Can I get a hardship exemption and get catastrophic minimum coverage for my dependents?

    • What you are asking is way more complicated than it sounds.

      Here’s what sounds like the relevant exemptions:

      Coverage considered unaffordable—The required contribution is more than 8.16% of your household income.

      .0816 unaffordable

      Please enter your information, so that we can see what you have to pay for coverage.

      Aggregate self-only coverage considered unaffordable—Two or more family members’ aggregate cost of self-only employer-sponsored coverage was more than 8.16% of household income, as was the cost of any available employer-sponsored coverage for the entire family.

      Coverage considered unaffordable based on projected income—The Marketplace determined that you didn’t have access to coverage that is considered affordable based on your projected household income.

      How is affordable coverage defined?

      Coverage is considered unaffordable for individuals if their cost of coverage exceeds 8 percent of annual household income.

      If an individual is eligible for employer coverage, affordability is determined by comparing the “employee share” of the premium cost of self-only coverage for the employer’s cheapest coverage option that achieves minimum value (i.e., 60% actuarial value) to the taxpayer’s household income.
      If the individual is not eligible for employer coverage, affordability is determined by comparing to household income the lowest cost bronze plan (taking into consideration any applicable federal premium subsidies) offered in the Exchange where the individual would purchase coverage.

      Even considering all that, does the premium difference between bronze and catastrophic make sense to do all the paperwork and hassle?

    • You might ask your employer to change his rules and not allow any dependents on the plan, as he’s not making any contribution anyway. Then you wouldn’t have the “family glitch.” Read above carefully for the citation.

      Affordability “Glitch”: This is only applicable to individuals that have an offer of coverage from their spouse’s employer. copied from Covered CA memo 1.31.2014

      What if the employer doesn’t offer family coverage?

      Some employers offer coverage for employees only, or for employees and their children, and do not offer spousal coverage. Large employers will face a penalty for failing to offer coverage to full-time employees and their children under the age of 26 if at least one employee receives a premium tax credit for marketplace coverage. There is no penalty for failure to offer coverage to the employee’s spouse. If no plan offered by the employer covers the spouse or children, the spouse or children may purchase insurance in the Marketplace and qualify for premium tax credits, assuming all other eligibility rules are met.

      It’s a new plan year and Jose’s employer has changed its coverage options. Now, Jose’s employer offers employee-only and employee-plus-children coverage. They’ve dropped the family coverage option so Alma no longer has an offer of coverage. Employee-only insurance costs $2,500 per year (7.1 percent of income) and coverage for the employee plus children costs $4,500 per year (12.8 percent of income). The “employee plus children” option is considered affordable, even though it costs more than 9.56 percent of income, because Jose’s employee-only insurance is affordable. This means that Jose and his children are not eligible for premium tax credits, whether or not they accept this coverage option. Alma doesn’t have an offer of coverage through her own or Jose’s employer so she may be eligible for premium tax credits to purchase coverage in the marketplace. Health Reform Beyond the Basics

      Here’s how Kaiser asks the question on their Employer Application…


      See also

  5. My employer will be providing a MEC – Minimum Essential Coverage plan through or Ben E Lect

    Does that keep me from the individual mandate penalty?

    If I don’t feel the coverage meets my needs, can I still get subsidies from Covered CA?

    • See the information above on “minimum value.”

      The American Worker website states that MEC is not minimum value, thus one would still be eligible for Covered CA subsidies.

      MEC [Minimum Essential Coverage] plans help employers meet one of the Employer Mandate penalties. By offering this level of qualifying coverage, employers will meet the requirement of offering “qualifying” coverage but not the requirement of “affordable” coverage. Employers must offer a Minimum Value Plan that meets the 60% Actuarial Value rule [Bronze] and affordability rules in order to avoid a $3,390 tax penalty for each employee who enrolls in a plan from the Exchange and receives a tax subsidy.

      See our webpage on budget plans for employers over 50 lives to avoid the tax penalties.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.